Why Your RSU Withholding Won't Cover Your Tax Bill in California

Your RSUs vested, your employer withheld taxes, and your brokerage account shows the net shares. It is natural to assume the tax is handled. For most California executives in the top bracket, it is not.
The 22% problem
RSUs generally create ordinary wage income when they settle, usually at vesting, whether or not you can sell the shares. Many employers withhold federal income tax at the optional flat 22% supplemental rate on the first $1 million of supplemental wages in a year, and must withhold at 37% above that. California withholds at 10.23%.
Your actual marginal rate can be far higher: up to 37% federal, up to 13.3% California, plus Medicare tax. Combined, that can exceed 52%.
What the gap looks like
Consider 1,500 RSUs vesting at $260 per share, or $390,000 of income, for an executive already in the top brackets.
Amount | |
Withheld (22% federal, 10.23% California, Medicare) | ~$134,900 |
Tax at top marginal rates | ~$205,300 |
Unfunded liability | ~$70,500 |
That $70,500 is due whether or not the shares can be sold. After an IPO, lockup periods and trading windows often mean they cannot.
Why this becomes a cash problem
The shortfall usually surfaces in April, along with underpayment penalties if estimated payments were missed. Executives who planned to sell shares to cover the bill may find the stock price lower, the window closed, or both.
How to plan ahead
Project the gap at each vest. Compare withholding against your true marginal rate, not the default rate.
Make estimated payments in the quarter the income arrives. Federal and California schedules differ. Federally, high earners can generally rely on 110% of last year's tax as a safe harbor; California does not allow this once AGI reaches $1 million ($500,000 if married filing separately).
Ask about higher withholding. Some plans let you elect a higher federal rate on vesting shares.
Pair vesting with offsets. Charitable gifts of appreciated stock, timed to high-income years, can absorb part of the spike.
Go deeper
RSU shortfalls are one piece of a larger liquidity picture. Our white paper, Navigating Mega-Cap Tech Exits: Tax Planning Before Your Lockup Expires, walks through ISOs, NSOs, and the structures that should be in place before a lockup expires.
Facing a large vest or liquidity event? Book a consultation with Unity Tax.
Illustrative figures assume top federal and California brackets and exclude California SDI, and assume the executive's supplemental wages for the year remain under $1 million. This article is not tax advice for your situation.
